Food for Agile Thought #517: The AI Boom-or-Bust Situation, Project vs. POM Debate, Testing Business Ideas, Agile’s Future?
Also: Bl**dy AI Features, Truth 2 Power, AI Adoption Report by Wharton
Hello everyone!
Welcome to the 517th edition of the Food for Agile Thought newsletter, shared with 40,352 peers.
This week, Grant Harvey dissects the AI boom-or-bust situation, warning of inflated valuations built on shaky economics. Petra Wille urges teams to switch deliberately between product and project thinking, guided by feedback loops, and John Cutler skewers empty calls for simplification that mask vague agendas and stalled change. Len Greski declares the “Agile” brand broken but defends its principles, while David Pereira’s chat with David J. Bland highlights lessons learned and why systems thinking now takes center stage.
Next, Maarten Dalmijn highlights how delaying decisions can preserve options and reduce regret. Raghav Sethi critiques AI bloat in products, eroding trust. Richard Mironov warns of inflated AI valuations and urges sharper judgment. At the same time, Eli Pariser reports from a private AI summit where hype meets unease. Also, Johanna Rothman reminds us that truth-telling requires cultural permission and consistent leadership.
Lastly, Jeremy Korst, Stefano Puntoni, and Sonny Tambe show that generative AI delivers ROI at scale, though skills still lag. Teresa Torres explains how Claude Code lets non-technical users build reusable AI workflows, and Maik Seyfert exposes the illusion of team autonomy rooted in structural control. Also, Mark Levison targets bloated backlogs with story maps. Finally, Nadzeya Stalbouskaya urges leaders to treat architectural debt as a strategic risk rather than hide it under the label of technical debt.
Did you miss the previous Food for Agile Thought issue 516?
🗞 Shall I notify you about articles like this one? Awesome! You can sign up here for the ‘Food for Agile Thought’ newsletter and join 40,000-plus subscribers.
🎓 Join Stefan in one of his upcoming Professional Scrum training classes!
🏆 The Tip of the Week
(via The Neuron): The Bull and Bear Case For the AI Bubble, Explained
Grant Harvey explores the AI market as both transformative and unstable, presenting detailed bull and bear cases. He argues that we are living through a genuine revolution, financed by an unsustainable, circular, and likely to correct financial bubble.
Source: The Neuron: The Bull and Bear Case For the AI Bubble, Explained
🎯 Product
Petra Wille: Why It’s Time to Forget the Project vs. Product Operating Model Debate
Petra Wille revisits the project-versus-product model debate, arguing it remains relevant in 2025. She encourages product teams to build fluency in both mindsets, using feedback loops to guide the proper framing for each type of work.
Source: Why It’s Time to Forget the Project vs. Product Operating Model Debate
Author: Petra Wille
Maarten Dalmijn: The Best Product Managers Optimize For Reversibility and Optionality
Maarten Dalmijn argues that great product managers embrace reversibility and optionality, delaying decisions until the last responsible moment. This mindset counters premature optimization and helps navigate uncertainty with better timing and fewer regrets.
Source: The Best Product Managers Optimize For Reversibility and Optionality
Author: Maarten Dalmijn
John Cutler: ‘We Have To Simplify!’
John Cutler satirizes vague calls to “simplify,” revealing how leaders often conflate cost-cutting, AI trends, and complexity without clear intent. The result is confusion, not clarity, and zero meaningful change.
Source: ‘We Have To Simplify!’
Author: John Cutler
Raghav Sethi (via makeuseof): I’m drowning in AI features I never asked for and I absolutely hate it
Raghav Sethi argues that tech firms are stuffing AI into products at the expense of usability and trust, turning once-simple tools and the broader internet into cluttered, less-human experiences.
Source: makeuseof: I’m drowning in AI features I never asked for and I absolutely hate it
Author: Raghav Sethi
🧠 Artificial Intelligence
(via Knowledge @ Wharton): 2025 AI Adoption Report: Accountable Acceleration: Gen AI Fast-Tracks Into the Enterprise
Jeremy Korst, Stefano Puntoni, and Sonny Tambe present findings from a three-year Wharton-led study showing Gen AI is moving from experiments to enterprise-wide ROI. Adoption is up, but capability building still lags behind ambition.
Rich Mironov: A Historical Take on the AI Boom
Richard Mironov compares past tech waves to AI, warning valuations exceed reality and a correction looms. He expects AI to become routine, with product managers needing sharper judgment to avoid shipping faster mediocrity.
Source: A Historical Take on the AI Boom
Author: Rich Mironov
Eli Pariser: What I Saw Around The Curve
Eli Pariser shares insights from “The Curve,” a private AI conference where optimism and unease coexist. Topics included AI acceleration, jagged capabilities, political fault lines, and the need to align AI societies, not just models.
Source: What I Saw Around The Curve
Author: Eli Pariser
Teresa Torres: Claude Code: What It Is, How It’s Different, and Why Non-Technical People Should Use It
Teresa Torres explains why Claude Code empowers non-technical users to build reusable, parallelized AI workflows. Unlike browser-based chats, it lets you own your data, automate research, and eliminate repetitive copy-paste work.
Source: Claude Code: What It Is, How It’s Different, and Why Non-Technical People Should Use It
Author: Teresa Torres
🖥 💯 🇬🇧 AI for Agile BootCamp #4 — November 6 — December 4, 2025
The job market’s shifting. Agile roles are under pressure. AI tools are everywhere. But here’s the truth: the Agile pros who learn how to work with AI, not against it, will be the ones leading the next wave of high-impact teams.
So, become the one who professional recruiters call first for “AI‑powered Agile.” Be among the first to master practical AI applications for Scrum Masters, Agile Coaches, Product Owners, Product Managers, and Project Managers.
Tickets also include lifetime access to the corresponding online course, once it is published. The class is in English. 🇬🇧
Learn more: 🖥 💯 🇬🇧 AI for Agile BootCamp #4 — November 6 — December 4, 2025.
Customer Voice: “The AI for Agilists course is an absolute essential for anyone working in the field! If you want to keep up with the organizations and teams you support, this course will equip you with not only knowledge of how to leverage AI for your work as an Agilist but will also give you endless tips & tricks to get better results and outcomes. I thoroughly enjoyed the course content, structure, and activities. Working in teams to apply what we learned was the best part, as it led to great insights for how I could apply what I was learning. After the first day on the course, I already walked away with many things I could apply at work. I highly recommend this course to anyone looking to better understand AI in general, but more specifically, how to leverage AI for Agility.” (Lauren Tuffs, Change Leader | Business Agility.)
➿ Agile & Leadership
(via Leading Agile): The Future of Agile Isn’t ‘agile’
Len Greski argues that the “Agile” brand collapsed under its own weight, but the underlying principles still deliver measurable business value. He outlines how structure, predictability, and risk management drive growth without the “Agile” buzzword.
Source: Leading Agile: The Future of Agile Isn’t ‘agile’
Johanna Rothman: Leadership Tip 23: How to Speak Truth to Power
Johanna Rothman reflects on how speaking truth to power requires cultural permission, congruent feedback, and courage. Leaders create fear through incongruence, but honest, well-framed stories can shift systems and restore alignment.
Source: Leadership Tip 23: How to Speak Truth to Power
Author: Johanna Rothman
Maik Seyfert: Team Autonomy Is a Beautiful Lie — Here’s What’s Really Holding Teams Back
Maik Seyfert argues that team autonomy often exists in name only, undermined by structural control, hidden dependencies, and leadership behaviors. Real autonomy requires clear mandates, reduced dependencies, and leaders willing to let go.
Source: Team Autonomy Is a Beautiful Lie — Here’s What’s Really Holding Teams Back
Author: Maik Seyfert
📯 AI 4 Agile v2 — I Need Your Input on What to Build Next
Version 1 of the AI for Agile Practitioners Online Course just closed its first two weeks with 250 new students. The feedback has been direct and useful: Practitioners value the realistic MegaBrain.io scenario work, the quiz design that tests judgment rather than memorization, and the focus on ethics and responsible AI alongside practical application. So far, that’s good, but AI 4 Agile v2 seriously needs your input: What topics shall I cover?
👉 Hence, please join the AI 4 Agile v2 Survey; it won’t take more than 3 minutes.
🛠 Concepts, Practices, Tools & Measuring
📺 David Pereira and David J Bland: Beyond Frameworks: Six Years of Testing Business Ideas
David Pereira interviews David J. Bland, who reflects on six years of real-world experimentation, admitting where his framework fell short and why systems, mindset, and AI now matter more than methods or teams.
Source: 📺 Beyond Frameworks: Six Years of Testing Business Ideas
Authors: David Pereira and David J Bland
Mark Levison: Drowning in an Oversized Product Backlog? Story Mapping Is Your Life Raft
Mark Levison argues that giant Product Backlogs kill clarity, motivation, and prioritization. He suggests replacing bloated lists with story maps to reconnect work to vision, focus on near‑term value, and drop stale items.
Source: Drowning in an Oversized Product Backlog? Story Mapping Is Your Life Raft
Author: Mark Levison
(via The New Stack): Technical Debt vs. Architecture Debt: Don’t Confuse Them
Nadzeya Stalbouskaya warns that confusing technical debt with deeper architecture debt masks systemic flaws that stall cloud and AI efforts. She urges treating architecture debt as a strategic risk with metrics and governance.
Source: The New Stack: Technical Debt vs. Architecture Debt: Don’t Confuse Them
📅 Training Classes, Meetups & Events 2025
Upcoming classes and events:
🖥 💯 🇬🇧 November 6-December 4 — Live Virtual Cohort: AI for Agile BootCamp Cohort (English)
🖥 💯 🇬🇧 November 10–11 — Live Virtual Class: Professional Scrum Master — Advanced Training (PSM II; English)
🖥 🇩🇪 December 9–10 — Live Virtual Class: Professional Scrum Product Owner Training (PSPO I; German)
👉 See all upcoming classes here
🗞️ Last Week’s Food for Agile Thought Edition
📺 Join 6,000-plus Agile Peers on YouTube
Now available on the Age-of-Product YouTube channel:
Hands-on Agile #68: How to Analyze Unstructured Team Interview Data with AI.
Hands-on Agile 2025: The 5 Obstacles to Empowered Teams — Maarten Dalmijn
Hands-on Agile 2025: The Top Reasons Why a Product Strategy Fails — Roman Pichler
Hands-on Agile 2025: Taylorism-Lean-Agile-Product Mindset — Jonathan Odo
Hands-on Agile Extra: How Elon Musk Would Run YOUR Business mit Joe Justice
🎓 Do You Want to Read More Like This?
Also:
📅 Join 6,000-plus peers of the Hands-on Agile Meetup group
🐦 Follow me on Twitter and subscribe to my blog, Age of Product
💬 Alternatively, join 20,000-plus peers of the Slack team “Hands-on Agile” for free.